InSinkErator Badger 900 Vs Badger 5XP – Detailed Comparison

In the realm of kitchen appliances, garbage disposals have transformed the way we manage kitchen waste. With countless models, the task of finding the perfect unit can be overwhelming.

When it comes to garbage disposals, the InSinkErator’s Badger series stands as a testament to efficiency and durability. Among the variants, the InSinkErator Badger 900 and the Badger 5XP have garnered significant attention.

This article aims to provide an in-depth comparison between these two models, exploring their similarities, differences, and ultimately assist you in making an informed decision tailored to your kitchen needs.

Comparing the InSinkErator Badger 900 and Badger 5XP is like evaluating two siblings: there are definite similarities, but also some key differences. Both models promise reliability and efficiency. However, the Badger 900 offers slightly more advanced features, while the Badger 5XP provides excellent value at a slightly lower price point.

Main Differences Between Badger 900 and Badger 5XP

FeatureBadger 900Badger 5XP
Width6.75 inches6.31 inches
Grinder MaterialStainless SteelGalvanized Steel
Warranty6 Years4 Years
Motor3/4 HP Dura-Drive Induction Motor3/4 HP Dura-Drive Induction Motor
Grinding Chamber Capacity26 oz26 oz


When comparing the Badger 900 and Badger 5XP, there are slight differences in the dimensions.

Although designed to fit under most standard kitchen sinks, the Badger 900’s compactness gives it an edge over the Badger 5XP, especially when kitchen space is at a premium. The dimensions become crucial when you’re working with limited under-sink space or have a highly compact kitchen layout.

The Badger 900 boasts a width of 6.31 inches and a height of 12.63 inches, making it a bit smaller than its sibling. Conversely, the Badger 5XP measures 6.31 inches in width and 14.5 inches in height, necessitating slightly more room.

The variation in size is minor, but it’s something to consider when comparing these two garbage disposal models.


One area where the Badger 900 has a clear advantage over the Badger 5XP is in the construction of its grinding components.

The grinding components of the Badger 900 are crafted from stainless steel, a material revered for its durability and resistance to rust. The Badger 5XP, on the other hand, uses grinding components made of galvanized steel. While reliable, galvanized steel may not resist corrosion as well as stainless steel.

Each of these models relies on a 3/4 horsepower Dura-Drive Induction motor, capable of delivering 1725 rpm. The motor’s efficiency combined with the superior grinding materials in the Badger 900 can contribute to longer life and improved performance.

However, the Badger 5XP still provides a commendable performance for its price, making it an excellent choice for those on a budget.


In terms of availability, the Badger 900 tends to be more widely accessible than the Badger 5XP.

The Badger 900 enjoys more widespread distribution, making it available across numerous commercial and online platforms, such as Home Depot. It’s crucial to check the availability of each model in your area as it can greatly impact the ease and speed of purchase.

Even though availability may vary based on location, overall, the Badger 900 seems easier to find. However, do note that availability shouldn’t be your sole decision-making criterion, as both models have their unique advantages.


The warranty period provided by the manufacturer is a crucial aspect of any product. For the InSinkErator Badger models, the Badger 900 holds an edge with a more extended warranty period. This model comes with a 6-year warranty, giving you an added assurance of its durability and the manufacturer’s confidence in the product.

The Badger 5XP is covered by a 4-year warranty. While shorter than its counterpart, it is still a respectable duration, showcasing the manufacturer’s commitment to product quality.

Although both models offer commendable warranties, the Badger 900’s more extended warranty provides an added layer of financial security to the buyer.


On the surface, both models share similar appearances but, a closer look reveals subtle differences.

Both garbage disposals are designed in a black and gray color scheme, but the placement and design of their logos vary. The Badger 900 showcases a more modern design, whereas the Badger 5XP sports a slightly more classic look.

However, these differences are purely aesthetic and do not affect the units’ performance. Additionally, considering that the disposals are installed under the sink, their appearance rarely affects the overall aesthetics of your kitchen.

Similarities Between Badger 900 and Badger 5XP


Despite their differences, the Badger 900 and Badger 5XP share remarkable similarities in performance.

They are both powered by a 3/4 HP Dura-Drive Induction motor running at 1725 rpm. This ensures consistent and powerful grinding capabilities, ready to handle most types of kitchen waste.

The high-speed motor combined with the grinding components can easily chew through vegetable scraps, fruit peels, coffee grounds, and more.

Regardless of the model you choose, both garbage disposals will provide efficient performance, keeping your kitchen sink free from food waste.


Interestingly, the height of the Badger 900 and Badger 5XP is quite similar, despite slight differences in their overall dimensions.

This similarity is a significant advantage as it ensures both models can comfortably fit under most standard kitchen sinks without requiring significant adjustments in the plumbing system.

Standardized height is an intentional design choice by InSinkErator, making the units more universally fit for different kitchen setups.

As a result, regardless of the model you choose, you likely won’t need to worry about significant adjustments in your under-sink space or plumbing.


When it comes to installation, both the Badger 900 and the Badger 5XP are user-friendly. They follow InSinkErator’s signature “Twist and Lock” design, employing the same 3-bolt assembly. This similarity makes the installation process straightforward, even for those with limited DIY experience.

Whether you choose to install the garbage disposal yourself or hire a professional, the process is relatively uncomplicated with both models.

If you’re looking to replace an existing unit with one of these models, the identical installation process makes the switch simple and hassle-free.


In terms of cost, the Badger 900 and Badger 5XP are similar. While there may be slight price variations based on the retailer or region, both models are designed as affordable, high-quality options in the garbage disposal market.

Both models are positioned as budget-friendly units without compromising on quality or efficiency.

So, whether you opt for the Badger 900 or the Badger 5XP, you can expect good value for your investment.

Can You Replace a Badger 900 With Badger 5XP?

Yes, replacing a Badger 900 with a Badger 5XP (or vice versa) is relatively easy, thanks to their identical installation processes and similar dimensions.

Both units use the same 3-bolt assembly with InSinkErator’s “Twist and Lock” design. This ensures a smooth replacement process, whether you’re upgrading or downgrading.

However, keep in mind the differences between the two models. If you switch from a

Badger 900 to a Badger 5XP, you may see a slight decrease in longevity due to the change in grinding component material. Conversely, upgrading from a Badger 5XP to a Badger 900 will provide enhanced durability and a longer warranty.

InSinkErator Badger 900 Vs Badger 5XP – Which One to Choose?

The choice between the Badger 900 and the Badger 5XP ultimately boils down to your specific needs and preferences.

If longevity, enhanced features, and a more extended warranty are high on your priority list, the Badger 900 may be the best option for you. On the other hand, if affordability and reliable performance are your primary criteria, the Badger 5XP will not disappoint.

Both models offer excellent performance and value for their price range. Therefore, the selection will likely depend on the specific features that appeal to you most and the budget you’ve allocated for a garbage disposal.


In conclusion, both the InSinkErator Badger 900 and the Badger 5XP stand as excellent garbage disposal options for any modern kitchen.

While they share several similarities, the differences in dimensions, grinding component material, availability, warranty, and appearance can influence your final decision.

So, choose the model that best aligns with your kitchen needs and budget, and you can look forward to a clutter-free, odor-free kitchen environment.

Similar Posts