Badger 5 Vs Badger 500 Vs Badger 5XL – What’s the Difference?

Garbage disposals are vital kitchen tools, providing an easy way to manage food waste while maintaining hygiene. InSinkErator, a renowned brand, offers an impressive line of garbage disposals, including the popular Badger series.

Among them, Badger 5, Badger 500, and Badger 5XL have become go-to choices for many households. But here’s the interesting fact: despite bearing different names, these three models are exactly the same. They are only sold exclusively at different stores.

All three disposals – Badger 5, Badger 500, and Badger 5XL – are identical in terms of performance, specifications, and features. The only difference is where you can buy them. Badger 5 is available at a range of stores, Badger 500 is exclusive to Home Depot, and the Badger 5XL is sold solely at Lowe’s.

Comparing Badger 5 Vs Badger 500 Vs Badger 5XL


Each model, whether it’s the Badger 5, the Badger 500, or the Badger 5XL, comes with a ½ horsepower (HP) Dura-Drive induction motor. This type of motor is known for its ability to deliver high torques at high speeds, ensuring efficient grinding of food waste. The motor operates at 1725 RPM, which is powerful enough to deal with most ‘garbage disposal friendly’ food wastes.

When comparing the Badger 5 Vs Badger 500 Vs Badger 5XL, their performance is virtually identical. All three are capable of handling the needs of small to medium-sized households effectively. It’s essential to remember that these are continuous feed models, meaning you can keep on adding waste while they’re running.

Feed Type

All three garbage disposals come in a continuous feed type. This means that you can keep adding food waste while the unit is running. Compared to a batch feed garbage disposal, which requires you to load the waste, close the lid, and then turn it on, continuous feed models like the Badger 5, Badger 500, and Badger 5XL are often more convenient to use.

As for their grinding capacity, each disposer holds 26 oz. of food waste at a time. This capacity is sufficient for a family of 2 or 3. But remember to feed waste gradually to avoid clogging.


In terms of dimensions, these three Badger models are identical. All the disposals are 11.5 inches in height, making them a suitable choice for most standard-sized kitchen sinks. Their compact size also makes them a good fit for tight spaces under your kitchen sink.

The main difference between Badger 5, Badger 500, and Badger 5XL lies in their marketing and not their design. Regardless of the model side by side, you won’t find any size difference.


The installation process for these three models is relatively straightforward, thanks to the Quick Lock sink mount feature. All you need to do is twist off the old disposer and twist on the new one. All three models use the same 3-bolt mounting system, ensuring a secure fit and easy installation.

If you’re a DIY enthusiast, you might appreciate the simple installation process. However, if you’d rather have professional help, InSinkErator also offers in-home service.


As mentioned earlier, all three models in this comparison of Badger 5, Badger 500, and Badger 5XL have a grinding chamber capacity of 26oz. This means that these disposals can hold that much food waste at a time.

While it may not be the largest capacity in the market, it’s certainly enough for most small to medium-sized households. Just remember not to overload them, as it could lead to jams or clogs.

Noise Level

When it comes to noise levels, the Badger series is not particularly known for being quiet. The Badger 5, Badger 500, and Badger 5XL lack the advanced noise insulation features found in more expensive models. However, their induction motors are comparatively quieter than permanent magnet motors used in some rival brands.

While these models won’t provide a whisper-quiet operation, their noise level is tolerable for most users. If the noise level is a significant concern for you, you may want to consider more premium models that offer sound-reducing technologies.


In terms of construction, the grinding chamber in these models is made of galvanized steel. This material is robust and corrosion-resistant, which extends the lifespan of the disposal. However, it’s not as durable as stainless steel, which is used in higher-end models.

Although the Badger series might not offer the same level of durability as its expensive counterparts, it still delivers reliable performance. It’s a well-made line of disposals that offer good value for money.


The warranty for the Badger 5, Badger 500, and Badger 5XL is also identical. All three models come with a 2-year in-home limited warranty from InSinkErator. This means that if anything goes wrong during the warranty period, InSinkErator will come to you in-home, covering parts and labor charges.

The warranty duration might not be as lengthy as what’s provided with some high-end models, but it’s relatively standard for disposals in this price range.

Reset Button

One feature found in all three models is the reset button, located at the bottom facing side of the unit. This button helps to reset the disposer if it becomes overloaded or jams. You can also use it to manually rotate the impellers if needed.

This reset feature can be a lifesaver when your disposal seems to be stuck or not functioning correctly, allowing you to solve minor issues without calling for professional help.

Power Cord

The last aspect to consider in this comparison of Badger 5, Badger 500, and Badger 5XL is the power cord. All three models come without a power cord, which means you’ll have to purchase it separately or use the one from your old disposal if it’s compatible.

While this may seem like an inconvenience to some, it’s pretty standard across many garbage disposal models. It gives you the flexibility to choose a power cord that best fits your kitchen setup.

Which One Should You Choose?

Since the Badger 5, Badger 500, and Badger 5XL are all the same garbage disposal, the best option will depend on where you prefer to shop. If you usually shop at Home Depot, go for the Badger 500. If Lowe’s is your preferred store, then the Badger 5XL is the way to go.

For those who shop elsewhere, the Badger 5 is available at multiple retailers. I recommend you go for the cheapest of the three, as the price is the only difference between them.

Check the best price of Badger 5 on Amazon here.


To sum up, the Badger 5, Badger 500, and Badger 5XL are essentially the same garbage disposal under different names. They offer the same performance, specifications, features, and even the same warranty. The only real difference is the retail store where they are sold.

Whether you choose the Badger 5, Badger 500, or the Badger 5XL, you’ll be investing in a reliable, efficient, and cost-effective garbage disposal that has earned its place in many homes. With good care

and proper use, any of these models will serve you well in managing your kitchen waste.

Similar Posts